Tree vandals face penalties up to $2.5 million under new NSW laws

Cleared bushland running down to the water at Woodford Bay in Longueville.
Woodford Bay foreshore after the clearing, November 2023. Photo: Councillor Kathy Bryla

At a glance

New NSW laws let councils take tree vandals to civil court for the first time. Individuals could face penalties of up to $500,000 and organisations up to $2.5 million.

The laws passed on Tuesday night and are expected to start in April 2027. Lane Cove MP Anthony Roberts supported them but says the penalties still don’t go far enough.

Councils will soon be able to take tree vandals to civil court for the first time. New laws passed NSW Parliament on Tuesday night without amendment and with near-unanimous support.

Individuals could face penalties of up to $500,000 and organisations up to $2.5 million. The changes are expected to take effect in April 2027.

Until now councils could only pursue criminal charges. These must be proved beyond reasonable doubt, so successful prosecutions have been rare. Civil cases have a lower bar.

The laws build on recent regulation changes that:

  • double on-the-spot fines for individuals from $3,000 to $6,000
  • triple fines for businesses from $6,000 to $18,000
  • let councils issue stop-work orders and enforce replanting
  • require a permit to remove dead or dying trees. This removes the incentive to poison them first

“2.5 million reasons”

Minister for Planning and Public Spaces Paul Scully said councils and communities had watched trees poisoned and ripped out without consequence.

“For too long councils and communities have seen trees poisoned and ripped out of their neighbourhoods for someone else’s convenience or profit without consequence.

“Today we’ve given vandals 2.5 million reasons to cut out this illegal and selfish behaviour.”

Closer to home

Cleared bushland on the Woodford Bay foreshore in Longueville after the illegal clearing in November 2023.
Woodford Bay foreshore after the clearing, November 2023. Photo: Councillor Kathy Bryla

Lane Cove knows the problem well. In November 2023 about 287 trees were illegally cleared from Council bushland at Woodford Bay in Longueville. Council later put up a giant banner to block the view the clearing opened up.

In August a gardener was convicted and fined $187,500 in the Land and Environment Court.

Separate proceedings linked to the clearing are still before the courts, so there are limits on what we can report (see the note at the end of this story).

The new civil penalties won’t apply to past cases. Mr Scully told Parliament the laws do not apply retrospectively.

In the Cove’s coverage of the Woodford Bay banner, September 2024.

It’s not just Lane Cove. North Shore MP Felicity Wilson told Parliament the trees around Balmoral Beach in Mosman have been repeatedly targeted by vandals. In one recent case, nine Port Jackson fig trees were found with holes drilled into them, raising concerns that poison had been injected into their roots.

“We have failed”

Lane Cove MP Anthony Roberts supported the laws. In his second reading speech on 11 November he argued the penalties are still too low where water views add serious value to a home.

“If someone calculates that they can destroy a tree, pay a fine and still come out financially ahead, then we have failed.”

He urged the Government to strengthen the deterrent and act quickly.

Lane Cove MP Anthony Roberts speaking in NSW Parliament on the tree vandalism laws. Video: Anthony Roberts MP/Facebook

In a statement through his office, Mr Roberts said courts should be able to go further when a vandal stands to gain more than the maximum penalty.

“The courts should be given greater scope to apply additional penalties if the financial benefit to the individual or corporation is greater than those penalties outlined in the Bill.”

Asked to respond, Mr Scully said the laws passed without amendment and with Mr Roberts’ support.

“These reforms put us in a much better position than any other previous government on this issue and were the product of extensive consultations.”

In his reply to the debate, Mr Scully said the Land and Environment Court will set penalties according to how severe the clearing is. He said that would make it more likely penalties are “big enough to offset the financial benefit gained through the commission of the offence”. Civil penalties will also be paid directly to councils to help them repair the damage.

Lane Cove Council has been asked whether it will use the new powers and whether the penalties go far enough. We’ll update this story when it responds.

Spotted tree vandalism?

Report it to Lane Cove Council on 02 9911 3555. You can read more about the rules at Protecting our urban trees and vegetation.

Our coverage so far

Why comments are closed

We know many locals feel strongly about what happened at Woodford Bay. Some proceedings linked to the clearing are still before the courts.

This isn’t about protecting anyone involved. It’s about the law. Under Australian law, publishers like In the Cove can be held legally responsible for comments posted on our website and social media pages, even though we didn’t write them. A comment that names someone or guesses who was responsible could affect a fair trial and expose us to legal action.

As a small independent local news site, that’s a risk we can’t take. So comments are closed on this story while proceedings continue. We’ll report on the outcomes when the courts have finished.

Got a view on the new penalties? Send it to us on [email protected]

Previous articleLove Landscapes: the Lane Cove team behind some of the North Shore’s best backyards
Renee is the Owner and Publisher/Editor-in-Chief of In the Cove, leading the publication's editorial direction, content, advertising and community partnerships. With a background in anthropology, she brings a natural curiosity about people and place to everything ITC publishes. As a proud Lane Cove local, Renee sees the suburb not just as where she lives, but as her community, her network and her home. That connection is what drives ITC's commitment to stories that matter to the people who live here.